Darnell Nurse and Cody Ceci are taking an excessive amount of blame for Edmonton's playoff loss. Right here's why

Article content material

Hockey gamers don’t normally say a lot in interviews, not that I’m complaining. If I used to be interviewed day-after-day about my efficiency, my bosses, my competitors and my enterprise I’d keep on with boring platitudes as nicely.

That stated, now and again a participant will spill the beans, which brings me to  the only most descriptive and damning remark in regards to the purpose the Edmonton Oilers misplaced to the Vegas Golden Knights. It popped out of Jonathan Marchessault’s mouth through the Oilers-Vegas sequence.

Commercial 2

Article content material

Article content material

Marchessault had simply scored three objectives within the second interval of Recreation Six, giving Vegas a 4-2 lead heading into the third. Sportsnet broadcaster Gene Principe grabbed Marchessault for just a few phrases as he was coming off the ice.

Close to the tip of the brief interview, Principe requested Marchessault what Vegas would wish to do to carry on to the lead and get rid of the Oilers.

And that’s when Marchessault dropped his reality bomb:  “If we hold bringing pucks to the online, we all know they play man-on-man within the d-zone, so we simply must beat our man to the online, and we will get bounces there.”

The remark was no insult. It wasn’t meant to be damning. It was simply telling like it’s.

But it might haven’t have minimize deeper into what went fallacious with the Oilers towards Vegas.

Vegas realized that Edmonton was locked right into a man-to-man defensive construction within the defensive zone. This method meant if Darnell Nurse was overlaying Reilly Smith, Nurse was to stay with Smith even when Smith ranged far out of the scoring zone in entrance of Edmonton’s internet, even when he moved out of the offensive zone.

It meant Oilers d-men like Nurse, Ceci and Mattias Ekholm had been continuously drawn away from the entrance of the Edmonton internet the place Vegas was so lethal scoring. It meant much less expert defenders, most frequently the Edmonton centre ice males, needed to fill that defensive void in entrance of the Edmonton internet.

Article content material

Commercial 3

Article content material

One can sense this won’t finish nicely, right?

Vegas responded with speedy motion via the offensive zone, shifting the Oilers gamers this manner, then that method, pulling the d-men as far out because the blueline.

And when Vegas sensed the Oilers had been out of sync, they might throw the puck at internet, hoping for a deflection or a rebound, a bit of excellent luck that created a free puck within the slot. All that needed to occur then was a Vegas attacker, comparable to Marchessault, to get to the online sooner than his Oilers examine, and he’d have a transparent Grade A shot of the best high quality.

As Marchessault so clearly described it: “We simply must beat our man to the online, and we will get bounces there.”

I dug into Edmonton’s systemic defensive woes in a latest put up the place I went over all 54 Grade A pictures for and towards the Oilers at even energy within the Vegas sequence. I discovered that on 9 Grade A pictures, 4 of them ending up as objectives towards, an Oilers d-men was caught wandering excessive out of the Grade A shot zone, however that this identical factor had not occurred as soon as to Vegas in their very own finish on a Grade A shot towards them. That’s as a result of Vegas didn’t play man-to-man, they performed a zone with two d-men stacked in entrance of the Vegas goalie.

Edmonton’s man-to-man was a part of the Sequence of Ache on extra than simply these 4 objectives towards. An Oilers fan primarily based in Florida, Justin Fox who independently had the identical concern in regards to the Oilers as I had and as Marchessault described dug into this identical subject in a latest Reddit put up.

Commercial 4

Article content material

Fox supplied the next critique of man-to-man defence in hockey: “My major downside with this type of man-to-man protection is the danger of a breakdown too typically results in such a excessive hazard likelihood that no profit is sweet sufficient to justify. It’s extraordinarily irritating to play nicely for 99% of the sport and nonetheless free the sport as a result of the unhealthy 1% virtually at all times finally ends up behind the online.

“Groups can scheme up breakdowns through the use of heavy motion within the zone, drawing defenders away from the online, and by creating authorized picks and tough switches for defenders to work via. Secondly, defenders usually are not in a very good place to dam pictures and clear rebounds as a result of their major focus is on their man. Lastly, fast transitions up ice are restricted by man protection, with defenders at all times going through the play or in positions away from the center of the ice.

“When considering particularly a couple of participant with Darnell Nurse’s defensive abilities and skating skill, he’s a participant that ought to thrive by conserving the play in entrance of him, blocking pictures, and getting up ice rapidly to hitch the frenzy. Good teaching ought to at all times be evaluating find out how to put their gamers in the very best place to succeed and getting Nurse again to being a dependable defender needs to be an offseason precedence for the Oilers.”

Commercial 5

Article content material

Fox’s conclusion: “The first purpose the Oilers underperformed and had been knocked out of the playoffs was their defensive staff construction. Whereas that may be a failure of execution by the gamers, a lot of the blame falls on the design by Woodcroft and Manson. I help them each, and imagine they’re the proper individuals to proceed main the staff, however this technique has to vary… A change away from this technique is, for my part, the only most important change — greater than any commerce, signing, or contract extension — that may be made for subsequent season’s staff.”

In his personal video evaluate, Fox discovered eight objectives towards the Oilers the place confusion and out-of-position defenders partly ensuing from Edmonton’s man-to-man method was an element. That’s half of the 16 objectives Vegas scored at even energy.

My very own conclusion?

What number of occasions did the Oilers appear to have Vegas contained on the assault, just for Vegas to fabricate a objective seemingly out of nothing. It’s these quite a few objectives towards that I hold fascinated by.

Gamers like Darnell Nurse and Cody Ceci have taken a beating on social media and on sports activities radio for his or her defensive miscues. But it surely’s now evident we had two d-men who had been doing their greatest to execute their directions.

Commercial 6

Article content material

No, Nurse and Ceci didn’t play excellent hockey. They made errors impartial of the defensive system. However the major challenge for them was making an attempt to execute a system that was flawed.

The identical goes for the centres, particularly Leon Draisaitl, Nick Bjugstad and Ryan McLeod, who typically struggled in defensive protection, both being sluggish to cowl in entrance of the online for a roving d-man or lower than tackling these ferocious slot battles. They’ve all been criticized, however, once more, within the title of being honest and correct, I’m going to counsel there needs to be extra give attention to the problem of their task versus their lack of execution.

I couldn’t agree extra strongly with Justin Fox’s evaluation. I don’t assume the Oilers defensive group is inferior to the d-men on Vegas. In actual fact, if Edmonton had performed a zone on this sequence and Vegas had performed man-to-man, I think the sequence would have been over in 5 video games, with Edmonton profitable it.

Oilers followers are targeted on Edmonton choosing up this participant or that participant this low season. However the actual distinction maker is for the Oilers coaches to deal with this tactical error and proper it.

Coach Jay Woodcroft is clearly a terrific communicator, a wonderful instructor and was a key in unleashing the attacking energy of this staff. However I’m glad he’s stated he’s going to be going over the videotape and on the lookout for issues that want altering. I think he’s already found out Edmonton’s man-to-man system needs to be revamped in favour of some sort of zone play.

Commercial 7

Article content material

Don’t imagine me? Take heed to Marchessault.

In a single easy sentence he described in assured phrases how easy it might be for Vegas to beat Edmonton’s defensive construction.

It’s damaged alright.

It’s as damaged as damaged might be.

Greatest to repair it. And I strongly suspect that’s precisely what’s going to occur.

Staples on politics

Not one Edmontonian in Danielle Smith’s cupboard, however a significant nod to town’s considerations

UCP cabinet
Alberta Premier Danielle Smith poses for an image with members of her cupboard on Friday, June 9, 2023 at Authorities Home in Edmonton. PHOTO BY GREG SOUTHAM /Postmedia

On the Cult

McCURDY: So many UFAs on Oiles, so little cap house. What to do?

LEAVINS: Who may Oilers be concentrating on on UFA market? 9 Issues

STAPLES: Analyzing Oilers’ defensive ways in Vegas sequence

McCURDY: Oilers operating to face nonetheless this low season

Article content material


Postmedia is dedicated to sustaining a full of life however civil discussion board for dialogue and encourage all readers to share their views on our articles. Feedback might take as much as an hour for moderation earlier than showing on the positioning. We ask you to maintain your feedback related and respectful. Now we have enabled e-mail notifications—you’ll now obtain an e-mail for those who obtain a reply to your remark, there may be an replace to a remark thread you observe or if a consumer you observe feedback. Go to our Neighborhood Pointers for extra data and particulars on find out how to alter your e-mail settings.

Be part of the Dialog

cial 1